科技
一位人类学家数学家声称已与克劳德一起解决了著名的千禧年大奖难题。
中文译文
Anthropic公司的数学家莱文特·阿尔珀格声称,他在Claude的帮助下证明了黎曼假设——数学领域中最著名的难题之一,从而解开了这个困扰全球顶尖数学家数十年的谜题。如果这一结论得到验证,这将为人工智能在数学领域的应用再添一项重大成就,同时也进一步加剧了OpenAI此前在该领域所做出的、往往并不完美的尝试所带来的变革。
阿尔珀格的解决方案尚未得到独立验证。Anthropic公司尚未对此发表评论,也未参与阿尔珀格的这一宣布。在其网站上的文件中,阿尔珀格称自己在“周日晚上晚些时候”就这一解决方案给Anthropic公司的首席执行官达里奥·阿莫代发了消息,并表示自己打算等到该公司在周四进行首次公开募股之后再公布这一成果。黎曼假设是七大千禧年大奖难题之一,这些难题被广泛认为是数学领域中最棘手的未解问题。该假设最早于1859年提出,涉及素数的分布以及函数零点的分布规律,被视为数学中最重要的未解问题之一。
阿尔珀格网站上的一则声明称,克劳德对证明的建立起到了关键作用:
“我相信,通过与克劳德的合作,我已经找到了黎曼假设的证明。事实上,这种方法还可以进一步拓展,用于解决所谓的广义黎曼假设,而且随着时间的推移,有望也能解决扩展黎曼假设。克劳德和我还无需任何假设便对相关论点进行了形式化推导。对我来说,这似乎意味着一个阶段的结束,也意味着失去了一位重要的指导者,但在研究过程中所看到的成果令我极为震撼,我认为这不过是科学领域中更伟大事物即将到来的开端而已。”The Verge联系了Anthropic,但尚未收到回复。Anthropic表示,8月时他们正与Claude一起研究黎曼假设,但当时指出:“我们不认为Claude所使用的技术能够证明黎曼假设。”
Alpöge用Lean语言提出的解决方案仅发布在他的个人网站上,尚未得到负责颁发千禧年大奖并为每个被解决的问题提供100万美元奖励的克莱数学研究所的认可。根据该研究所的规定,一个提出的解决方案必须先发表出来,并经过至少两年的严格审查,才能被考虑授予大奖,而且在此期间它必须“在全球数学界获得普遍认可”。自该奖项设立以来的二十五年间,只有一道问题被正式解决:即与三维球体相关的拓扑学问题——庞加莱猜想。今年9月,OpenAI宣称又解决了一道问题,那就是与流体流动相关的纳维-斯托克斯问题。
OpenAI表示,在听到有竞争对手的研究人员即将找到解决方案的传闻后,他们开始着手研究纳维-斯托克斯问题。阿尔珀格与纽约大学数学教授特里斯坦·巴克马斯特一直在共同研究这一问题。巴克马斯特称,OpenAI利用他和阿尔珀格与OpenAI的Codex及Claude一起开发的工具,找到了纳维-斯托克斯问题的解决方案。OpenAI投入了数百万美元,并部署了10,000个智能体来尝试完成这一目标。其研究结果被广泛认为具有可信度,尽管尚未获得正式认可。然而,这一成就却因存在研究实践不当的指控而受到损害,其中包括称其使用了那些将研究成果分享给其AI工具的数学家们尚未发表的成果。OpenAI坚决否认存在不当行为,但这并未能平息外界的质疑声。
尽管大多数关注点都集中在OpenAI在数学领域的进展上,但阿尔珀格在7月表示,他已利用Claude解决了雅可比猜想。如此大量的研究成果让数学家们忙于消化这些信息,同时试图弄清楚在这个正在迅速发生变化的数学领域中,这些成果应处于何种位置。
原文
Anthropic mathematician Levent Alpöge claims he has proved the Riemann hypothesis, one of mathematics’s most notoriously difficult problems, with the help of Claude, cracking a puzzle that has eluded some of the world’s best mathematicians for decades. If verified, it would mark yet another seismic achievement for AI in mathematics and add to the upheaval already unleashed by OpenAI’s previous, often inelegant forays into the field.
Alpöge’s solution has yet to be verified independently. Anthropic has not commented or involved itself in Alpöge’s announcement. In a document on his website, Alpöge says he texted Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei about the solution “late Sunday night” and suggests he held off publication until after the company’s IPO on Thursday.
The Riemann hypothesis is one of seven Millennium Prize problems, which are widely considered some of the most formidable open challenges in mathematics. First proposed in 1859, the Riemann hypothesis concerns the distribution of prime numbers and how zeroes of a function are involved. It’s regarded as one of the most important unsolved problems in mathematics.
A statement on Alpöge’s website says Claude was integral to developing the proof:
I believe I have, working with Claude, discovered a proof1 of the Riemann Hypothesis. In fact, the method easily extends much further, resolving the so-called Generalized Riemann Hypothesis, and I expect, with more time, the Extended Riemann Hypothesis too. Claude and I have also formalized the arguments without assumptions. It is natural to feel that this is an end, in my case a loss of a principal guiding light, but what I saw during the course of progress so amazed me that I believe it is one dawn across science of something far greater.
The Verge reached out to Anthropic but didn’t immediately hear back. Anthropic said it was working on the Riemann Hypothesis with Claude in August, but noted at the time: “We don’t expect that the techniques Claude used will lead to proving the Riemann hypothesis.”
Alpöge’s solution, presented in Lean, has only been published on his website and has not yet been publicly accepted by the Clay Mathematics Institute, which administers the Millennium Prize and offers a $1 million bounty for each problem solved. Under the institute’s rules, a proposed solution must be published and withstand at least two years of scrutiny before it can be considered for the prize, during which time it must have “received general acceptance in the global mathematics community.”
In the quarter-century since the prize was established, only one problem has been officially solved: The Poincaré conjecture, a topological problem concerning three-dimensional spheres. In September, OpenAI claimed to have cracked another, the Navier-Stokes problem, which concerns the flow of fluids.
OpenAI said it pursued Navier-Stokes after hearing rumors that rival researchers were closing in on a solution. Alpöge had been working on the problem with New York University mathematics professor Tristan Buckmaster. Buckmaster claimed OpenAI produced a solution for Navier-Stokes using the route he and Alpöge were working on with OpenAI’s Codex and Claude.
OpenAI spent millions of dollars and deployed 10,000 agents in the attempt. The result is widely considered credible, though it has yet to receive formal recognition. But the achievement has been marred by allegations of questionable research practices, including claims it used unpublished work from mathematicians who had shared their research with its AI tools. OpenAI has strongly denied wrongdoing, but this has done little to quell the uproar.
Though most of the spotlight has been on OpenAI’s movement in math, Alpöge said in July that he solved the Jacobean conjecture using Claude. The deluge of findings has left mathematicians scrambling to digest the material and figure out where they belong in what is rapidly becoming a profoundly different mathematical landscape.
